Landmark Court Victory Against the Balkans’ Largest Coal Plant sets European Precedent: “Coal has No Legal Future”

SOFIA – In a historic victory for environmental justice, the Supreme Administrative Court of Bulgaria has definitively revoked the operating permit of Maritsa East 2, the largest coal-fired power plant on the Balkans. The landmark ruling, handed down today, concludes a seven-year legal battle led by Greenpeace Bulgaria and Za Zemiata (Friends of the Earth Bulgaria), with support from ClientEarth, proving the state-owned plant operated in flagrant violation of toxic air pollution standards.

The court ruled that the national Executive Environment Agency can no longer grant unchecked exemptions for sulfur dioxide and mercury emissions. Effective immediately with the final judgment, all future regulatory decisions must prioritize public health and rely on rigorous scientific data.

Setting a Powerful Precedent for European Climate Litigation

This victory is far more than a local success story; it sets a critical legal precedent that reverberates across the continent. For years, fossil fuel giants have bypassed environmental regulations by arguing their individual emissions are economically necessary and that their specific impact is minimal. Today's ruling completely dismantles that defense by solidifying two powerful precedents:

1. The Principle of Cumulative Impact: The court ruled that governments cannot grant pollution exemptions in a vacuum. If a region’s air or water is already heavily polluted, regulators are legally forbidden from granting further waivers. This standard provides a plug-and-play roadmap for lawyers to challenge fossil fuel permits based on the cumulative health toll on communities.
2. Scientific Evidence Guides the Court: The permitting authority must consider 'all relevant scientific data' regarding pollution, not merely the reports produced by the operator. This establishes a higher standard for assessment that the authority must meet and creates opportunities for citizens and organizations to participate more meaningfully in the decision-making process.This victory injects massive momentum into a global wave of strategic climate litigation, serving as a warning to the 3,262 large industrial installations across the European Union as of 2024 data, 25% of which are not aligned with the most robust requirements of the European environmental legislation.

The Deadly Cost of Delay vs. The Clean Solution

Coal kills, and delaying its phase-out carries a devastating human toll. A health impact assessment by the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA) revealed that postponing the decommissioning of Bulgarian coal plants would cause 5,500 premature deaths, 132,000 cases of childhood asthma, and €11.1 billion in health costs across the region.

Furthermore, these heavy pollutants directly supercharge the climate crisis, fueling the severe droughts, floods, and extreme weather events that threaten vulnerable families worldwide.

"This ruling is a victory for fairness, safety, and a healthy environment. It proves that governments can no longer protect outdated, polluting technologies at the expense of human lives," stated Meglena Antonova, Director of Greenpeace Bulgaria. "But critique must be paired with cooperation. We are calling on governments to stop defending obsolete fossil infrastructure and start working collaboratively on early, planned coal phase-outs that protect workers through a just transition to clean energy."

A Tale of Two Neighbors: Reclaiming Regional Solidarity

The ruling highlights a stark regional contrast in climate progress and shared purpose. While Bulgaria has fought to keep its aging coal fleet on corporate life support, neighboring Greece recently closed its largest coal plant and is on track for a total coal exit by the end of this year. This court victory protects Greek citizens who have been exposed to cross-border pollution drifting from Bulgaria's coal fleet, proving that true energy security relies on collective regional progress.

The economic and legal reality worldwide is undeniable: coal is a stranded asset, and renewable energy is the safest, most affordable path forward. Environmental organisations urge governments globally to voluntarily design rapid, fair coal phase-outs, reinvest public funds into community-led solar and wind power, and secure a safe climate for the next generation.

###

Editor’s Note: The full judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of Bulgaria, the European Environment Agency's industrial tracking datasets (referencing 2024 operations), and the CREA research results are available upon request.